15 Best Restaurants in Stonington, Maine

Are you visiting Stonington? Would you like to know the best restaurants in Stonington, Maine? 

Stonington is a town situated in Hancock County, Maine, USA. It has a population of slightly over a thousand people after the 2020 census.

From the get-go, people appreciated Stonington for its natural store of physical resources. The mid-1700s saw the arrival of European settlers.

Stonington’s rich repository of an assortment of seafood made it an attraction to sea-loving, seafood-craving settlers, tourists, and business people.

Some interesting places to visit are the Stonington’s Sand Beach, Stonington’s Opera House, Stonington’s Mini Village, Stonecutter Statue Site, and lots more.

Are you planning a food tour of Stonington? Here are the top restaurants in Stonington, Maine.

Best Restaurants in Stonington, Maine 

1. The Harbor Café

The Harbor Café

The Harbor Café is a vibrant eatery in the middle of Stonington, Maine. They use high-quality, farm-fresh ingredients for their dishes and provide a warm, inviting environment for their diners. You’ll love it at The Harbor Café.

It’s fitted for social gatherings of various kinds, such as eating out with family, hanging out with friends, having a dinner for two with that special person, holding meetings with colleagues, meeting up with special group members, and so on.

You can try out The Harbor Café’s nachos, cheese, and chocolate tea. They also offer cheese quesadillas, chicken fingers, cheesy bacon fries, French fries, sweet potato fries, homemade onion rings, chicken wings, mozzarella cheese sticks, jalapeno pepper poppers, broccoli with cheese bites, and more.

They swing their doors open for business from 6:00 am – 2:00 pm on Sundays and Wednesdays. They open from 6:00 am – 2:00 pm and 4:30 pm – 7:30 pm on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays. They’re closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.

Address: 36 Main St, Stonington, ME 04681 Phone: +1 207-367-5099.

2. Stonecutters Kitchen

Stonecutters Kitchen

Stonecutters Kitchen, which used to be Fihserman’s Friend Restaurant, is situated in downtown Stonington. It is one of the best Stonington restaurants.

Order all the great edibles you crave and sit in the serene, welcoming environment to relish your meal while you view the busy waterfront of Stonington.

You can have your entrees for lunch or dinner with loved ones at Stonecutters Kitchen. It’s an interesting place to visit if you love waterfronts and enjoy seafood.

Stonecutters Kitchen’s seafood-based dishes are made from sea-fresh supplies to delight their diner’s taste buds and nourish their diners.

Amidst their fresh seafood, which includes “Maine seafood,” a special dish, they also offer some of the best wings in Stonington.

Their menu also features classic Crotch Island onion rings, French fries, summer salad, classic Caesar salad, classic Downeast haddock, fish tacos, chicken tacos, Tony burgers, grilled chicken sandwiches, fried chicken sandwiches, and so on.

They open their doors for business from 11:00 am – 7:00 pm on Mondays to Saturdays and 12:00 pm – 7:00 pm on Sundays.

Address: 5 Atlantic Ave, Stonington, ME 04681 Phone: +1 207-367-2530

3. Cockatoo Portuguese Restaurant

Cockatoo Portuguese Restaurant

Cockatoo Portuguese Restaurant brings a piece of Portugal to Stonington, Maine. Here, you’ll find and taste classic Portuguese cuisines to the bliss of your taste buds.

They’ve served locals and tourists for a while and have become one of the top restaurants in Stonington, Maine, for excellent Portuguese fares.

Stonington doesn’t have a better place to eat Portuguese cuisine than the Cockatoo Portuguese Restaurant, which provides its diners with a welcoming ambiance.

The Cockatoo Portuguese Restaurant operates from 12:00 pm – 8:00 pm on Wednesdays to Saturdays. They’re closed on Sundays, Mondays, and Tuesdays.

Address: 24 Carters Ln, Stonington, ME 04681 Phone: +1 207-348-2300.

4. Stonington Ice Cream Company

Stonington Ice Cream Company

Stonington Ice Cream Company is more than your standard ice cream outlet. At Stonington Ice Cream Company, you’ll find more than ice cream.

In addition to your favorite flavors of ice cream, you’ll find red onion relish, capers and chives, smoked salmon in baguette, beef tenderloin sandwich served with chef’s special sauce, and other award-winning seafood-based fares.

They open their doors for business from 11:00 am – 8:00 pm on Mondays to Saturdays and 12:00 pm – 8:00 pm on Sundays.

Address: 66 Main St, Stonington, ME 04681 Phone: +1 207-367-2900

5. Aragosta at Goose Cove

Aragosta at Goose Cove

The proprietor and executive chef of Aragosta at Goose Cove is Devin Finigan. Downeast Magazine recently named Aragosta at Goose Cove “Main’s best waterfront restaurant” for good reasons.

Chef Finigan had good cooking ingrained into her by her father, who was himself a great chef who served in Vermont.

She grew up amidst the mountains of Vermont, where she started to hone her culinary art. She started working in and around kitchens, fixing delicacies, and delighting her diners from age 14 and has not taken a break since then.

Over time, as she progressed in her culinary career, she’s had to work with some of the best in the culinary industry, such as Jean-Georges Vongerichten, Thomas Keller, Dan Barber, and Kyle Connaughton.

Finigan travels the world in her quest for culinary inspiration to create the most delightful experiences for her diners through the creativity she comes away with from kitchens worldwide after taking such trips.

She makes her dishes from locally sourced, farm-fresh materials to give her diners great quality and value.

Among many delectable edibles, Aragosta at Goose Cove offers burrata salad, blackened fish tacos, Aragosta burgers, lamb kofta pizza, seafood mezze platter, and more.

Aragosta at Goose Cove opens to serve the public from 4:00 pm – 8:00 pm on Mondays to Wednesdays and 5:00 pm – 8:15 pm on Thursdays to Saturdays. On Sundays, they open earlier for business and have two sessions. They open from 10:30 am – 2:30 pm and 5:00 pm – 8:15 pm.

Address: 300 Goose Cove Rd, Deer Isle, ME 04627 Phone: +1 207-348-6900

6. Stonington Seafood

Stonington Seafood

Stonington Seafood is the place to go for the freshest, juiciest, and tastiest seafood in Stonington, Maine. It sis revered one of the top restaurants in Stonington, Maine. Stonington Seafood is suitable for family dine-outs, friends meet-ups, special group meetings, etc.

At Stonington Seafood, you’ll eat some of the best finnan haddie, guaranteed! Finnan haddie is one of many dishes the chef at Stonington Seafood knows how to craft with expertise.

You’ll also find that the Stonington Seafood menu is rich with taste-bud-enthralling edibles, such as Cullen skink, which is a Scottish smoked haddock dish, eggs benedict, smoked haddock with mashed potatoes, kipper pate, and more.

Address: 536 Sunshine Rd, Deer Isle, ME 04627 Phone: +1 207-348-2730.

7. Inn on the Harbor

Inn on the Harbor

Inn on the Harbor is more than a restaurant – it’s a full-blown hotel that dates back to the 1880s and is nestled on Stonington’s picturesque harbor.

Owing to its age-long standing in the hotels and inns industry, it has mastered the craft of great customer care and awesome service to ensure visitors’ optimal satisfaction.

Inn on the Harbor has built a reputation for having a spectacular and charming view of the Penobscot Bay islands, which lodgers love to enjoy as they relish their dishes acquired from restaurants nearby.

The inn provides a serene and romantic waterfront resort for lovers of nature and great views who live in Stonington or visit Stonington.

It offers free Wi-Fi and a free parking lot. It is also pet-friendly and smoke-free.

Address: 45 W Main St, Stonington, ME 04681. Phone: +1 855-695-7070.

8. Coldwater Seafood

Coldwater Seafood

Coldwater Seafood is one of the best seafood outlets in Stonington, Maine. Coldwater Seafood is your ideal resort if you’re looking to recline and enjoy some juicy seafood after the day’s toiling and moiling.

They make the dishes with the best sea-to-table fresh ingredients, which give the Coldwater Seafood dishes their delightful tastes and result in returning diners.

Other than classic seafood, Coldwater Seafood also offers beef hamburgers, beef short ribs, salted cod fish, smoked salmon pate, porterhouse steak, and so on.

They open their doors for business from 10:00 am – 4:00 pm on Mondays to Thursdays and 10:00 am – 5:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays. They’re not open for business on Sundays.

Address: 100 N Main St, Stonington, ME 04681 Phone; +1 207-348-3084.

Are you considering more exploration of Maine? Here is our list of things to do in Ogunquit, things to do in Augusta and things to do in Freeport for a fun vacation.

9. Boyce’s Motel

Boyce’s Motel

Situated in the heart of the picturesque fishing community of Stonington, Boyce’s Motel has played host to more than five decades of first-time and return diners, welcoming them to the comfort and warmth of their family-owned and family-run business. 

Boyce’s Motel overlooks the beautiful Harbor of Stonington and is within range of other shops and eateries, some of which are the Stonington Opera House and the Isle au Haut mail boat.

Address: 44 N Main St, Stonington, ME 04681. Phone: +1 207-367-2421.

10. El El Frijoles

El El Frijoles

El El Frijoles is located in Sargentville, Maine, it is a Mexican restaurant that specializes in crafting Mexican delicacies. It is the brainchild of a husband and wife who established it in 2007.

If you are in this part of Maine, this restaurant is worth a visit.

Its founders modeled it after the taquerias (Mexican restaurants) distributed in the San Francisco Bay region where the husband and wife first met.

El El Frijoles presents burritos, tacos, quesadillas, and empanadas with a special touch that makes them delightfully interesting and richly complex.

They offer a delicious blend of classic Mexican street fare and Downeast Maine’s collection of delicious, farm-fresh, local ingredients.

They make it spicy and interestingly flavorsome. They marinade an assortment of hot sauces from around the globe in definite proportions to get exactly what they know you’ll find irresistible. They’re masters of their craft.

There are nine seats inside while several picnic tables, benches, boulders, and even elevated lawns are modified to serve the dining purpose and accommodate delighted diners who love the natural and unique setting.

There’s also a wide space for kids to play. Very often, kids spontaneously play a game of soccer or badminton close to the sandbox as their parents, siblings, and friends watch delightfully.

El El Frijoles is, without a doubt, one of the best places to eat in Stonington, Maine. It is the place to go with family and friends for memorable, fun moments together.

Their menu holds chips and salsa, oaxacan corn bowls, quesadilla, nachos, pollo cocido, carnitas, grilled veggies, rajas y papas, beans with cheese, carne asada, cabbage ensalada de la paz, and so on.

They’re open for business from 11:00 am – 7:00 pm on Wednesdays and Thursdays. They’re closed for the rest of the week.

Address: 41 Caterpillar Hill Rd, Sargentville, ME 04673. Phone: +1 207-359-2486.

11. Dot and Millie’s

Dot and Millie’s

The spring of 2019 marked when Amy and Kelly, Dot and Millie’s founders, quit their jobs and contacted a real estate agent to sell their house. It is located in Vinalhaven and one of the best restaurants near Stonington.

They packed their stuff, picked up their canine friends, and drove cross-country to begin a new venturesome life in Vinalhaven.

They made a great decision, as they later realized and acknowledged. They loved the people, the island, and the food.

They named Dot and Millie’s after their grandmothers – Dorothy (Amy’s grandmother) and Mildred (Kelly’s grandmother).

Amy and Kelly treat their diners like family or friends who are visiting them in their home for dinner. They’ll be delighted to have you visit.

They’ve provided a relaxing, inviting environment to eat your delicacies.

They offer starters, entrees, and desserts. Their menu holds fish cakes, grilled pizza, margaritas, meatballs, salads, Caesar salads, tomato with burrata, steak fries, lobster pappardelle, ravioli, seafood stew, pan-seared chicken, short ribs, and so on.

It opens for business from 5:00 pm – 8:30 pm on Thursdays to Saturdays. They’re closed for the rest of the week.

Address: 49 E Main St, Vinalhaven, ME 04863. Phone: +1 207-863-2300.

12. Fin and Fern

Fin and Fern

Andrew Chappell is a savvy French cuisine chef and an alumnus of Johnson and Wales’ Culinary Arts Program.

In 2019 he arrived Maine, which he calls “home,” and is excited to serve the community with his expert culinary skills. Andy carries thirty years of culinary expertise and experience to Fin and Fern, where he’s the chef.

He’s served in chartered yachts, private homes, and fancy restaurants in the United States, Australia, Bermuda, Caribbean islands, and Mexico.

Now that he’s finally home in Stonington’s seaside community, Andy is set on making the kind of food he enjoys.

Therefore, Fin and Fern, is undoubtedly one of the outstanding Stonington restaurants. You’ll be glad you stopped by for a meal at Fin and Fern.

Fin and Fern opens from 4:00 pm – 7:30 pm on Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. They’re closed on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays.

Address: 25 Seabreeze Ave, Stonington, ME 04681. Phone: +1 207-348-3111.

13. Carta’s Seafood

Carta’s Seafood

Carta’s Seafood makes seafood with fresh-from-the-sea ingredients. It’s a place to go for relaxation, delight, and nourishment after a hard day’s work.

Carta’s Seafood makes all kinds of seafood-based dishes with their diners’ bliss and satisfaction in mind.

They’re open for business from 8:00 am – 4:00 pm on Sundays to Mondays.

Address: Oceanville Rd, Stonington, ME 04681. Phone: +1 207-367-0900

14. Little Bay Seafood

Little Bay Seafood is nestled in Stonington, a scenic fishing site. Over time, Little Bay Seafood has hosted new and repeat customers to their tested-and-confirmed seafood haven.

Diners keep returning for more because they taste quality and warmth at Little Bay Seafood.

Address: 31 Bayview Ave, Stonington, ME 04681. Phone: +1 207-367-5020

15. Jones Lobster Company

Jones Lobster Company

Jones Lobster Company takes pride in serving tasty meals to its diners.

They’re masters of making seafood to the delight of their satisfied diners. Their meals are cooked to perfection, decently priced, and served in ample portions.

They open their doors to serve the public from 10:00 am – 5:00 pm on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. They’re closed on Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays.

Address: 179 Sunshine Rd, Deer Isle, ME 04627. Phone: +1 207-348-6768.

Map of the Best Restaurants in Stonington, Maine 

To get around during your trip to Stonington, here is a map of the best restaurants in Stonington with markers of the top places to eat in Stonington, Maine.


Are you considering more exploration of Maine? Here is our list of things to do in Camden, things to do in Old Orchard Beach and things to do in Rockland for a fun vacation.

Plan a Visit to Stonington

As a waterfront fishing community, Stonington flaunts more seafood restaurants than most other places you might have visited in the country.

Nevertheless, you’re sure to find something in st least one of Stonington restaurants that suits your gourmet fancy.

If you’ve been to Stonington and visited any of the restaurants on our list, please feel free to share your experiences with our reading community.