In search of the best restaurants in Olean, NY?
Olean is a city in Cattaraugus County, New York, United States. It is the county’s largest city. Its population was about 13,786 after concluding the 2021 census.
It is a financial, business, and entertainment center of the Southern Tier region of Western New York. This city is filled with diverse people. Hence, a majority of the population are immigrants from different countries and cultures.
There are several fun places to visit at Olean. Some include Lincoln Park, Rock City Park, Pfeiffer Nature Center & Foundation, and St. Mary of the Angels Basilica. There are also wonderful hotels like Hampton Inn & Suites, Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott, and more.
By now, you must have discerned that Olean is not some boring city in New York. To compliment the city’s awesomeness are numerous excellent restaurants. These Olean restaurants offer diverse meals, including those of foreign nationality.
Are you planning a food tour of Olean? Here are the best restaurants in Olean, NY.
Restaurants in Olean, NY
1. Union Tea Café
Union Tea Café is a perfect New York-style tea shop. It serves espresso, coffee, tea, and premium beverages. Union Tea Café serves some of the best coffee & tea pairings, ranging from cookies and donuts to sandwiches and salad.
The environment is very conducive and airy, with beautiful outdoor seating provisions. The restaurant’s owner is a woman named Amy Sherburne. It is one of those low-key breakfast cafes where you can breeze in and out because it is not too busy.
Some of the menu offerings include scones, biscuits & gravy, waffles, pistachio cake, French dip, cheese dip, roast beef sandwich, and so on. You can visit their website to view the restaurant’s full menu list or follow their social media handles.
While enjoying your breakfast at Union Tea Cafe, you can opt for coffee, smoothie, latte, candy cane tea, and milkshakes. Union Tea Café opens by 8 am and closes by 3 pm daily.
Address: 301 N Union St, Olean, NY 14760-2635. Phone: +1 716-701-4014
2. Mirchi Bar & Grill
Who wouldn’t love a cozy restaurant serving American comfort foods. Mirchi Bar n Grill is such a delightful diner for solo or group dining in Olean, NY. Mirchi Bar & Grill is a colorful, unassuming restaurant with vintage decorations. It is revered as one of the top Olean restaurants.
This restaurant serves happy hour drinks, fried calamari, orange chicken, small chicken shashlik, and steaks. It is an enjoyable hub for comfort dishes and drinks, especially if you choose to sit outdoors to enjoy the iconic views better.
The popular menu picks are steak salad, pretzel sticks, fish & chips, liver & onion rings, chicken sandwiches, and hashbrowns. These and all other menu items are homemade with love and culinary passion. You should not forget to try their mango lassi drink. It’s very delicious.
Mirchi Bar n Grill is a great place to eat sandwiches, burgers, and desserts. They open early in the morning by 7 am and close by 8 pm.
Address: 1020 N Union St, Olean, NY 14760-1430. Phone: +1 716-790-8473
3. The Old Library Restaurant
The Old Library Restaurant is one of the best restaurants in Olean, NY. It is a seafood establishment on suites 116 & 120 South Union Street, Olean, NY. According to their mottos of “bringing fare from the sea” and “nothing beats homemade,” it leaves patrons with a lot of hints concerning the restaurant.
The Old Library Restaurant was built in 1909 partly with the financial help of Andrew Carnegie. It is situated right inside the historic Olean Public Library Building. You will be impressed by its old-world architectural charm and bookshelves all around.
It serves prime ribs, braised lamb shank, bruschetta, pesto pasta, crème Brulee, carrot cake, ramen noodles, gnocchi, and more. You can be sure to enjoy the rich taste of all the restaurant’s foods. We recommend you try its chicken wellington. If not, then order the well-prepared and elegantly presented duck s l’orange.
Address: 116 South Union Street 120 South Union Street, Olean, NY 14760-3634. Phone: +1 716-372-2226
4. Oishi Sushi & Hibachi LLC
Do you crave delicious sushi? Oishi is a Japanese restaurant in Olean, NY, that serves the best-tasting sushi, hibachi, and other Japanese entrees. The restaurant is a sure bet for authentic Japanese cuisine.
Oishi Sushi & Hibachi LLC provides the best of the best cucumber sushi deluxe. It’s a must-try if you’re in Oishi because it is delicious. They prepare very tasty hibachi steak, which has turned into customers’ favorite. Be sure to eat hibachi steak with chicken shorts and red wine. You’ll thank me later.
One of the menu items that are popular at Oishi is spring rolls with sweet chili sauce. Just staring at it is a savory experience and even more tasty than you might have assumed. They open by 11 am and close by 8.30 or 9.30 pm daily.
Address: 2232 W State St, Olean, NY 14760-1900. Phone: +1 716-373-8889
5. Angee’s
Angee’s Restaurant is a wonderful Italian restaurant that is family-owned. It supplies classic Italian dishes such as pizza, sandwiches, burgers, and wines to the Olean, NY, community.
Aside from the fine Italian dining experience at Angee’s, customers love the cozy environment and free wifi that characterizes this eatery. Angee’s was founded by late Angelo Fratercangelo in 1948. Some 60 years later, his son Nicholas Fratercangelo took over the family business ownership and full operations. He has retired, and it’s now the 3rd generation son Anthony Fratercangelo that is currently running Angee’s since 1988.
The restaurant serves sweet spaghetti, meatball sandwich, tiramisu, artichoke dip, and cannoli. They also serve sumptuous chicken marsala, which can be paired either with beer, wine, or fruit juice. The restaurant’s menu list includes French fries, sausage sandwiches, mussels, and rolls.
Address: North Union Street, Olean, NY. Phone: +1 716-373-7070
6. Tasta Pizza
Tasta Pizza is an eatery offering traditional and specialty pizzas in this veteran pizzeria with a mini-golf course. It is one of the best places to eat in Olean, NY. This pizza restaurant sticks to its culture of preparing pizzas in custom-built coal ovens. They have been doing so since its inception in 1970.
They make gluten-free wraps and vegetarian options for all customers who prefer those. They offer all three service options: dine-in, carryout, and online delivery. Some of the meals they offer, in addition to pizza, include garlic knots, tater tots, pinwheels, garlic rotolis, garlic rolls, meatballs, and BBQ bacon burgers.
Some of the rich pizza flavors they offer on their menu include Margherita pizza and Pepperoni pizza, and there’s even an option to make your personal pizza. They open by noon and close by 8-9 pm daily, including weekends.
Address: 1521 W State St, Olean, NY 14760-2039. Phone: +1 716-373-2393
7. Rafi’s Platter
Rafi’s Platter is a new American restaurant serving classic comfort foods with modern culinary flavors and styles. Some of the foods they serve include chicken curry, Pakistani platter, and spicy lentil soup. These three foods are among the restaurant’s specialties.
Baked French onion soup is a fantastic food to order at Rafi’s restaurant. You can also go for their chicken kabob or ambers spicy chi tikka masala with shrimp. The latter is surely going to satisfy you even if you’re a picky foodie.
Rafi’s Platter serves lobster Mac & Cheese in a unique way. The same is observed with their gyro, crispy vegetable samosa, and butter & garlic noodles. They open by 11 am and close by 8 pm on weekdays.
Address: 800 Wayne St, Olean, NY 14760-2266. Phone: +1 716-790-8294
8. Century Manor
Century Manor is one of the best restaurants in Olean, NY. It is an eatery meant for casual dining at an affordable price.
It serves drinks, onion soup, spinach, sticky buzzard honey, blue-collar ribeye, crème Brulee, gnocchi, and stuffed mushrooms. Shrimp on the Barbie is the restaurant’s daily special that you should consider ordering.
Century Manor’s ahi tuna is a great dish that is exceptionally delicious. They are delicious and well-seasoned for anyone’s taste buds. The restaurant opens by 4 pm and closes by 9 pm daily. Fridays are veterans’ days.
Address: 401 E State Street, Olean, NY 14760. Phone: +1716-372-1864
Also, check out our list of things to do in Port Jefferson, and things to do in Yonkers, for a fun vacation in New York.
9. Grand Slam Grill
Grand Slam Grill is one of the best places to eat in Olean, NY. They serve wings, steaks, burgers, wraps, pork chops, and more. Grand Slam Grill serves delicious steak sandwiches, NY strip steak, stuffed mushrooms, New York-style cheesecake, shrimp kabobs, spaghetti & meatballs, and pub burgers and fries.
Fried calamari, loin pork chop with Jalapenos, mile-high peanut butter pie, onion ring towers, and more. On-deck donut burger is a fantastic lunch food at Grand Slam Grill.
They serve drinks like a blue moon, Stella Artois, and other cocktails. They open by 11 am and close by 8-9 pm, except for Sundays and Mondays.
Address: 3132 Nys Route 417, Olean, NY 14760-1835. Phone: +1 716-379-8870
10. Beef ‘n’ Barrel
Beef n Barrel is among the highest-rated Olean restaurants. It has old-fashioned American wood and stained-glass fixtures. The restaurant is known for its high-quality, tasty meals, particularly its signature roast beef.
They serve rolls, baked French onion soup, southwestern BBQ chicken salad, horseradish, and so on. Chicken fingers with BBQ sauce is a good pick, but some might prefer chicken wings instead to go with the BBQ sauce because its portions are bigger.
Shakes and cocktails such as daiquiri, pina colada, hot fudge, and strawberry shortcake drink are available. The restaurant’s attention to detail while serving food and the surrounding design elements make it stand out. It opens by 11 am and closes by 9 pm daily except Sundays.
Address: 146 N Union St, Olean, NY 14760-2735. Phone: +1 716-372-2985
11. Brother’s Bistro
Want to drink and socialize at a bistro in Olean? Brother’s Bistro is the spot to go to. It is the highest-rated pub in Olean, New York. The bistro offers Cajun-tinged New American fare in a simple yet modern setting.
Brother’s Bistro is family owned and operated by two brothers, Husnain and Ahsan Rafi. They’re two passionate chefs who specialize in American and Mediterranean cuisine. They began small, and the bar turned out to be Brother’s Bistro. This establishment is a gastropub meaning a restaurant with food and drink offerings.
They serve shrimp & grits, tandoori scallops, beef tenderloin kabab, tandoori chicken tikka, chicken souvlaki pita, and more. Many of the food menu items are seafood dishes. We recommend their French onion soup for dinner. It is delicious and well-seasoned.
Some like to eat voodoo shrimp appetizers before pounding on their shrimp & grits. The restaurant offers takeaway, and preordering prior to pickup; this ensures a fast service. The restaurant operates only in the evening, thus making it a great place for a fun night with friends and family as you dig into your seafood. They open by 5 pm and close by 10 pm.
Address: 188 N Union St, Olean, NY 14760-2716. Phone: +1 716-379-8656
12. Perkins Restaurant & Bakery
Perkins Restaurant & Bakery is a kid-friendly chain known for baked goods, breakfasts, and other meals. Perkins Restaurant & Bakery is very good at producing yummy baked goods that have many franchise locations across the US. It offers customers curbside pickup, dine-in, and delivery services.
The Olean branch of Perkins serves pancakes, country-fried steak & eggs, French toast, cinnamon rolls, and others. The menu is filled with breakfast classics to eat in the morning.
The restaurant’s staffs are welcoming. In addition, it’s environment is cozily coupled with that savory bakery aroma. Perkins opens by 7 am and closes by 10 pm daily.
Address: 2728 West State St, Olean, NY 14760. Phone: +1 716-373-3610
13. Green Acres Café
Green Acres Café serve crème Brulee French toast, French toast & eggs, cheeseburger & fries, and Reuben sandwich.
You can also find a grilled fare on the menu, which means that your breakfast plate can contain a BBQ pork sandwich and fries or grilled chicken. Western omelets are also available at this amazing breakfast restaurant.
Green Acres Café opens by 8 am and closes by 2 pm daily.
Address: 133 N Union St, Olean, NY 14760-2736. Phone: +1 716-373-5670
14. The Broken Wing Pizzeria & Grille
The Broken Wing Pizzeria & Grille offers the best fish fries in Olean, NY. Cajun chicken bruschetta cold wrap is their customers’ pick. Carrot cakes are the best desserts in The Broken Wing Pizzeria & Grille.
This restaurant provides scotch ale, a local craft beer that many customers enjoy. The Broken Wing Pizzeria & Grille provides various pizza flavors, including cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, beef sausage pizza, and so on.
You can choose to go for their delicious chicken wings, either smoked, grilled, or fried. Most of the grilled seafood go with beer, so you have nothing to worry about if you’re a beer lover. Now, head to The Broken Wing Pizzeria & Grille and enjoy yourself!
Address: 313 Main St, Olean, NY 14760-2607. Phone: +1 716-373-5600
15. 3rd Base
3rd Base is one of the top restaurants in Olean, NY, due to its meals rich taste. Chicken wings, medium wing basket, grilled Daryll wings, prime rib sandwich, Reuben sandwich, and more are served here. 3rd Base is a restaurant composed of a steakhouse, bar, and grill. 3rd Base serves delicious food in a bistro setting with abstract art that creates intrigue. The place is kid-friendly, so the whole family can come here for dinner in high chairs.
Here, they serve pizza, burgers, steaks, seafood, salads, soft & alcoholic drinks, and full-course meals or buffet. This is truly a classic American restaurant with all its dine-in advantages. It is wise to make reservations before coming to dine in.
We would recommend the prime rib sandwich with fries and deep fried pickles, along with a mocktail like the Moscow Mule. Many customers reportedly enjoy the Atlantic salmon served at this fine restaurant. There is even grilled cheese available which will be a pleasure to try out.
Chicken & waffles, Fish & Chips, hamburgers, Chicken fried steak, and tacos are all specially prepared and taste good in this restaurant.
Address: 1302 W State St, Olean, NY 14760-2036. Phone: +1 716-372-8779
Map of the Best Restaurants in Olean, NY
To get around during your trip to Olean, here is a map of the best restaurants in Olean with markers of the top places to eat in Olean, NY.
Want more places to visit in New York? Here is a guide on things to do in Greenport, things to Do in Flushing and things to Do in Cooperstown for an amazing time.
Plan a Visit to Olean
We have seen that Olean is one of the best cities to visit in New York. Olean restaurants are havens for foodies because they offer tasty, high-quality meals.
So, don’t hesitate to make the city your next relaxation location. Its features are sure to make your stay memorable.