Greencastle, Indiana, is a small city in Putnam County, approximately 45 miles west of Indianapolis. It is the county seat of Putnam County and had a population of around 9,983 people as of 2021.
The city is home to DePauw University and several other small educational institutions.
Greencastle restaurants caters to different tastes, whether they prefer traditional American comfort food or foreign cuisines.
There are many fast-food joints and pizza establishments to select from. In addition, Greencastle offers sit-down experiences and quick bites. So, there is something for everyone.
Are you planning a food tour of Greencastle? Here are the best restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana.
Best Restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana
1. Almost Home Restaurant
For more than three decades, diners have enjoyed the food at Almost Home Restaurant, located in the center of Greencastle, Indiana, on the north side of the courthouse square.
They have had the distinction of serving modern cuisine in a welcoming setting over the years.
They are eager to serve you, whether you eat in, place an online order, or use their onsite and off-site catering services.
The eatery offers a selection of breakfast, lunch, and dinner options in addition to serving traditional American cuisine. Burgers, sandwiches, tacos, salads, and more items are available on the menu.
You’ll understand after just one bite why almost every visitor order one of their delectable, freshly crafted desserts. Additionally, you can order desserts in advance for your event.
On Monday and Thursday, the restaurant is open until 8 pm; on Tuesday and Wednesday, it’s open until 4 pm; and on Friday and Saturday, it’s open until 9 pm.
It’s a beautiful location for gathering with loved ones for dinner, unwinding, and taking in the surroundings.
Address: 17 W Franklin St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-5788
2. Bridges Craft Pizza & Wine Bar
The quaint Indiana town of Greencastle is home to Bridges Craft Pizza & Wine Bar. It is tucked away in the city’s center, surrounded by charming shops, eateries, and other local establishments.
The setting is warm and welcoming, with an industrial-chic vibe. Additionally, this establishment has a rooftop patio.
There is no place like The Rooftop, as it offers views of Greencastle and Putnam County’s surroundings. They open The Rooftop for drinks, cocktails, and a lighter dining menu from late spring through early fall.
Their menu offers a range of recipes for soups and salads, small plates, pasta, sides, and desserts. In addition, delicious artisan pizzas and an extensive wine selection are offered on the menu.
Tuesday through Saturday, this eatery is open from 5 pm until 9 pm. The days Sunday and Monday are closed.
The establishment is ideal for a date or a fun night out with friends, as it is one of the best restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana.
Address: 19 N Indiana St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-0021
3. The Putnam Inn
The parents of the current owners, Ron and Jane Hansen constructed the Putnam Inn in 1972. In 1998, their daughter Rhonda and son-in-law Chris acquired control and continued the family heritage of providing home-style food at competitive prices.
The restaurant keeps a calm atmosphere while providing a tempting buffet with more than 50 delicious options. Beverages available at Putnam Inn include bottled and draft beer, wines, and cocktails.
The restaurant has comfortable booths and tables, and the warm and inviting ambiance makes it ideal for a family reunion or romantic evening.
The menu features a wide selection of traditional American cuisine, from steaks and seafood to sandwiches and salads.
Some shareable items on their menu include chicken wings, fried Brussels sprouts, and Bavarian sourdough pretzels with house-made beer cheese.
The Putnam Inn is open from 11 am to 9 pm from Tuesday through Saturday and closed on Sunday and Monday.
Join the Putnam Inns family today to enjoy a supper you will remember!
Address: 400 N Jackson St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-8777
4. Myers’ Market
Mitch Myers had an idea in 2013: he wanted to bring the neighborhood butcher shop back to Greencastle, focusing on the best meats and locally made goods to help make dinners memorable.
That same emphasis is still present today at Myer’s Market. This restaurant offers all-natural deli selections, catering, USDA Prime steak cuts from the Midwest, including beef and pork farm in Indiana.
Myer’s Market is a top-notch deli and a butcher shop. Additionally, they provide catering for your events.
Weekly specialties include a variety of sandwiches. You can also find cheeses, bread, vegetables, condiments, chips, and fountain drinks on their menu.
Myer’s Market is open from 10 am to 6 pm every Tuesday through Friday. They are closed on Sunday and Monday but open on Saturday from 9 am to 3 pm.
This restaurant is a great place to meet up with friends and family for a casual meal.
Address: 302 E Washington St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-1335
5. Moores Bar & Grill
You are treated like family at Moore’s Tavern & Grill, a neighborhood bar. Their motto is “Good food, Great friends, Cold beer.” Since 1950, Moore’s Bar and Grill has been a favorite landmark in Greencastle for locals of all ages, as such, it is revered as one of the best places to eat in Greencastle, Indiana.
They don’t just provide excellent cuisine and beverages; they also foster a warm, welcoming environment where each patron is treated like a member of the family.
At Moore’s Bar and Grill, the welcoming Midwest is still very much in evidence. You will always be able to find someone to talk to whether you arrive with friends or on your alone.
Since Moore’s Bar began in 1950, the menu has altered a few times, but one thing has remained constant: the delicious comfort cuisine that goes nicely with their full bar and a wide variety of domestic and craft beers.
Hot loaded fries, hand-breaded chicken tenders, Billy Burger with secret sauce, and luscious ribeye steak sandwiches are on their menu.
This restaurant’s working hours are from 11 am to 1 am from Monday to Saturday.
So, whether you stop by for lunch or make our location your regular hangout, their friendly community will make you feel at home.
Address: 17 S Indiana St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-9939
6. The Fluttering Duck
In the sleepy college town of Greencastle, Indiana, lies a charming eatery called The Fluttering Duck. The historic DePauw University campus is nearby and situated in the city’s center.
The Fluttering Duck is a laid-back and welcoming venue where you may have a casual family dinner, unwind with friends after work, watch football, or eat outside on the terrace.
Greencastle’s visitors, students, and locals can enjoy outstanding dining experiences at The Fluttering Duck.
You’ve found the perfect place when you want to watch a game or catch up with friends over a small batch of bourbon and a burger at The Fluttering Duck.
There are chicken tenders, nachos, loaded fries, spinach and artichoke dip, and vegetarian quesadillas on the menu at this eatery.
Patron will enjoy televised sports, live music on Fridays, and summer nights on the patio. The Fluttering Duck is one of the best places to eat in Greencastle, Indiana.
On Monday through Friday, this restaurant is open from 11 am to 10 pm, and on Saturdays, it is open from 2 pm to 10 pm. They are closed on Sunday.
Address: 2 W Seminary St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-658-1000
7. Don Julio
Don Julio is a Mexican restaurant located in Greencastle, Indiana. The restaurant is one of the outstanding Greencastle restaurants. It has a cozy and welcoming ambiance and is housed in a historic structure.
The restaurant’s interior is decorated in a Mexican-inspired style, with bright lighting, brightly colored tile floors, and a traditional Mexican theme.
The eatery has inviting booths, tables, and lively décor, enhancing the ambiance. Visitors can relax on a terrace outside with seating for outdoor dining or just to enjoy the fresh air.
Tacos, enchiladas, and burritos are a few of the conventional Mexican foods on the menu. Specialty items like chiles, Rellenos, and quesadillas are also available. The restaurant also offers a variety of tequilas, margaritas, and Mexican beers.
Don Julio is open from 11 am to 9 pm on Sunday through Thursday, and on Friday and Saturday, it is open from 11 am to 10 pm.
Don Julio is a fantastic place for a night out with friends or family because of its lively atmosphere and excellent meals.
Address: 11 W Franklin St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-630-8525
8. Marvin’s
Greencastle, Indiana’s lovely village, is home to Marvin’s restaurant. It is situated in the city’s center on a peaceful street with quick access to all the sights.
The restaurant provides a welcoming ambiance with a blend of traditional and modern furnishings. There are several places to sit inside, including high-top tables, booths, and cozy rockers.
The menu offers a selection of burgers, sandwiches, salads, and other classic American comfort foods.
The restaurant has a complete bar and a wide selection of beer and wine. Marvin’s is a terrific place for a night out because there is frequent live music and entertainment on the weekends.
Wheelchair access is available, and takeout is available.
Tuesday through Thursday, this restaurant is open from 11 am to 2 pm and from 5 pm to 10 pm. On Friday, it is open from 11 am to 2 pm and from 5 pm to 12 am.
On Saturday, it is open from 5 pm to 12 am, and they are closed on Mondays.
Address: 202 S College Ave, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-9200
Plan to explore the cities of Indiana, check out our guide on restaurants in Wabash , and restaurants in Castleton for fun exploration.
9. Dairy Castle
In the quaint Indiana village of Greencastle, tucked away in the region’s undulating hills, is where you can find Dairy Castle.
It is a fantastic location for your quick treats. Classic American fare like burgers, shakes, malts, and sundaes are offered on the menu, along with regional delicacies like Hoosier Pie and Sugar Cream Pie.
The crew is constantly prepared to deliver top-notch service in a pleasant, welcoming environment.
On Tuesday through Saturday, this restaurant is open from 11 am to 9 pm, and on Sunday, it is open from 12 pm to 9 pm. They are closed on Mondays.
Address: 801 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-9222
10. The Breakfast Co
On January 16, 2018, The Breakfast Company unveiled its first location in Crawfordsville, Indiana. Doris Kline Maples, who launched The Breakfast Company, started her career in the restaurant business in 1993 after being employed by Pete Avgerinos, a close friend and mentor.
They provide a wide selection of breakfast and lunch selections and healthier versions. In addition, they provide breakfast all day, so no worries if you want it for noon.
Come and indulge in some mouthwatering pancakes, an omelet, and more! Also available are catering services. Choosing the appropriate caterer for your occasion is crucial.
They will take care of every little detail for you and ensure that your event runs smoothly. In addition, they offer a wide variety of meals and are pretty accommodating.
Every day from 6 am to 3 pm, this eatery is open.
Address: 1746 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-630-3959
11. Taco Wapo Burrito Factory
In the center of Greencastle, Indiana, is a lively and entertaining Mexican restaurant. Taco Wapo Burrito Factory is one of the top restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana, given its extensive customer base.
Customers are welcomed inside the restaurant by its lively, colorful ambiance and excellent, authentic Mexican food. They also offer a kids’ menu for children, so there is something for everyone.
Many different types of food are available at the restaurant, including tacos, burritos, quesadillas, enchiladas, and others.
All dishes have an unmatched original flavor because they are produced using fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
A comprehensive bar with a fantastic assortment of beers, wines, and spirits is also available at the restaurant.
From Tuesday through Sunday, they are open from 11 am to 9 pm; they are closed on Monday.
All guests are guaranteed a positive experience thanks to the staff’s friendliness and attention to detail.
Address: 306 E Washington St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-0169
12. 2 West Bistro
In the sleepy Indiana hamlet of Greencastle, you’ll find 2 West Bistro. This bistro-style restaurant is located inside the inn at DePauw.
The restaurant provides a warm, friendly ambiance with warm lighting and cheery furnishings. American food is offered on the menu, with various dishes ranging from appetizers to entrees.
Seasonal and daily specials are also included on the menu. The restaurant also features a full bar with regionally produced wines, spirits, and craft brews.
Some of the products to anticipate on their menu include the smoked sausage triple grilled cheese, the southwest chicken wrap, and the French onion grilled cheese.
The restaurant features a full salad bar, homemade soups, and a monthly seasonal menu.
The personnel are responsive and helpful, and the environment is welcoming and cheerful. The 2 West Bistro is a fantastic spot to eat whether you’re looking for a particular date night or just a relaxed supper with friends.
From Monday through Friday, this eatery is open from 7.30 am until 2.30 pm. Sunday and Saturday are closed.
Address: 2 W Seminary St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States, Phone: +1 765-658-1000
13. Monical’s Pizza of Greencastle
In the bustling area of Greencastle is Monical’s Pizza, which is locally owned and run.
Monical’s Pizza of Greencastle has served delectable pizza, sandwiches, salads, and more for many years. It is situated on the corner of Seminary and Anderson Streets.
Locals love the restaurant because of its handy location, big meals, and affordable costs.
A wide selection of pizzas, including specialty pies like the Cheese Lovers and the Veggie Supreme, are available.
Additional options, including sides, desserts, and special meals, are available to customers.
There are many tables and a full-service bar with a selection of drinks in the bar area.
This restaurant is open from 11 am to 9 pm every day.
Monical’s Pizza of Greencastle is the place to go whether you’re looking for a fast lunch, a family supper, or a late-night snack.
Address: 29 Putnam Plaza, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-301-4404
14. Casa Grande Mexican Restaurant
Greencastle, Indiana, has a family-friendly restaurant called Casa Grande Mexican Restaurant. It is among the excellent Greencastle restaurants.
Tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and fajitas are just a few of the traditional Mexican foods served at the restaurant.
A full bar with a variety of tequilas, margaritas, and other cocktails is also available at the restaurant.
It’s a beautiful place to share a dinner with family and friends because of the welcoming ambiance and courteous personnel.
Try the Casa Grande Nachos, their specialty meal, for a singular experience.
The restaurant is open from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm on Sunday through Thursday, and on Friday and Saturday, it is available from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm.
They are sure to sate your appetites because they are stuffed with your favorite Mexican toppings.
Address: 1360 Indianapolis Rd, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-2309
15. Jackson’s Double Decker Family
In the center of Greencastle, Indiana, you may find the iconic American diner Jackson’s Double Decker Family Restaurant. It is one of the best restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana.
The restaurant has a long tradition of producing delectable and filling fare. In addition, the restaurant’s interior decor creates a warm and nostalgic atmosphere.
Everyone may find something on the menu which offers all-day breakfast, sandwiches, burgers, salads, and other options.
The double-decker burger, a two-patty topped with cheese, bacon, and all the fixings, is the restaurant’s unmistakable offering.
Generally speaking, it is where you can obtain good meals in a casual setting. Jackson’s Double Decker is the ideal location for supper with the family or a laid-back evening out.
This restaurant is open every day from Monday through Friday from 7 am to 8 pm and on Saturday and Sunday from 7 am to 2 pm, except Thursday.
It is a favorite among locals and visitors because of the welcoming service and delectable meals.
Address: 509 S Bloomington St, Greencastle, IN 46135, United States. Phone: +1 765-653-4708
Map of the Best Restaurants in Greencastle, Indiana
To get around during your trip to Greencastle, here is a map of the best restaurants in Greencastle with markers of the top places to eat in Greencastle, Indiana.
Plan to explore the cities of Indiana, check out our guide on things to do in Warsaw, things to do in Mishawaka , and things to do in Carmel for fun exploration.
Plan a Visit to Greencastle
Greencastle is known for its rich history and culture. It is a friendly and welcoming community with plenty of opportunities to enjoy the outdoors, participate in cultural activities, and meet new people.
In addition, Greencastle restaurants offers an exciting experience to make your visit more memorable.