Looking for the best restaurants in Castleton, Indiana?
Castleton is a neighborhood in Marion County, in Lawrence and Washington townships, in northeastern Indianapolis, Indiana, United States. It has a population of over 10,000 people.
Castleton is a commercialized area. It boasts various clothing stores, Asian supermarkets, fashion retail shops, and magnificent restaurants with eclectic offerings.
Castleton is one of the best places to live or go for tourist attractions. In addition, living here offers residents an urban-suburban life feel.
Although Castleton is a popular place to visit for relaxation, most tourists enjoy its hospitality and fine dining. There is no dull moment in the food scene of Castleton. Hence, your taste bud will have something to relish and appreciate.
Are you planning a food tour of Castleton? Here are the best restaurants in Castleton, Indiana
Restaurants in Castleton, Indiana
1. Harry & Izzy’s Northside
If you find yourself around River Edge and crave nicely curated seafood, pizzas, and chops, you should consider Harry & Izzy’s Northside. The menu has a lot to try, as the inviting atmosphere makes the experience perfect.
A dish of Radiatori Pasta with lemon chicken, pancetta, basil, tomatoes, and white wine is a great way to announce your presence. If there is space, you can add a plate of salad or brownie dessert and crème Brule. Check out the daily specials; there is something for everyone on the list.
The ambiance is comfortable and radiates style. Hence, the spot is perfect for hosting your special ones or quiet dining. Service is always prompt and fast, a good reason you should experience eating here.
Harry & Izzy’s Northside is open on Monday to Thursday, from 11 am – 10 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 11 am – 11 pm, and Sunday, from 11 am – 9 pm.
Address: 4050 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 915-8045
2. Ale Emporium
Opened in 1982, Ale Emporium is a prominent restaurant in Castleton’s neighborhood, serving a selection of American comfort food. It offers a sports pub feel, with a tune of live music that greets guests in the evening.
If you need clarification about what to eat, you should go for their chicken sandwiches or burgers. There are many of them with different flavors you would love. A plate of salad and a bottle of beverage or soft drink can make a light meal. There is also an excellent selection of craft, draft, or on-the-tap beers.
In addition, the restaurant also offers a sports atmosphere, with a flat-screen showing favorite games. There are big, relaxed couches with neon lights around the dining to make it more intimate. You would love to revisit the restaurant after your first encounter, as it’s one of the best restaurants in Castleton, Indiana.
Ale Emporium is open on Monday to Thursday, from 11 am – 1 am, Friday to Saturday, from 11 am – 2 am, and Sunday, from 12 pm – 12 am.
Address: Bottom of Form8617 Allisonville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 842-1333
3. Charleston’s Restaurant
Among the top restaurants in Castleton, Indiana, is Charleston’s Restaurant. It is famous for many reasons, especially its casual atmosphere and consistency in taste and approach to American comfort food. Its dishes are made from scratch, with high-quality ingredients, and served hot and tasty.
Are you thinking of what you would eat here? A simple dish of prime rib and salad may be all you need to warm up your heart with its tender, juicy, and flavorful emergence. You may also consider specialties like the Rigatoni Bolognese, served with Italian sausage, tomato, oregano, garlic, parmesan, and red pepper cream sauce.
While savoring your meal, the flat-screen television shows your favorite sports to entertain you. The casually stylish setting adds beauty to the whole experience, giving you a magical feel. Meanwhile, it costs a little to enjoy the premium service provided by this beautiful diner.
Charleston’s Restaurant is open on Monday to Saturday, from 11 am – 10 pm, and Sunday, from 11 am – 9 pm.
Address: 6815 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 841-0442
4. Metro Diner
This local spot is close to Castleton, serving classic Southern breakfast and brunch. Stop by whenever you are around and let the professional servers take care of your appetite. Metro Diner is family-owned, focusing on made-to-order food served in a warm environment.
As you step in and grab a seat in a comfortable position, you should indulge in some bold and inventive meals. First, try some home-style signature items like Fried Chicken and Waffles. Alternatively, Bissell breakfast containing two eggs, hash browns, pancakes, and two strips of bacon is worth tasting.
The evocative setting takes you back to the 50s, yet the atmosphere gives an elegant appearance. Your family and friends will love to join you for refreshing dining on one of the jolly evenings. The food portion is large, so you can share, as laughter and happy faces make a memorable experience.
Metro Diner is open on Monday to Thursday, from 7 am – 3 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 7 am – 8 pm, and Sunday, from 7 am – 5 pm.
Address: 3954 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46240. Phone: (317) 296-8262
5. The District Tap
This restaurant is situated along Clearwater Crossing and radiates a quaint and rustic atmosphere. It features music, games, local beer, and bar-style dishes.
The extensive menu has everything you crave, from burgers to salads, appetizers, chicken sandwiches, and seafood. Another hearty meal worth a try is Chicken and Shrimp Alfredo, made with fettuccine pasta tossed with Alfredo sauce, garlic, shrimp, and red onions. The craft beer on tap is damn good and deserves your tasting, too.
If you are looking for a local spot to listen to live music and relax after a hectic day, why not make the District Tap your must-visit? It is one of the best places to eat in Castleton, Indiana, and has everything that offers comfort, including fun trivia nights, games, and televisions.
The District Tap is open on Sunday to Saturday, from 11 am – 12 am.
Address: 3720 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46240. Phone: (317) 288-8251
6. Twin Peaks Restaurants
Opened in 2005, Twin Peaks Restaurants is a sports bar-like restaurant providing Southern comfort cuisine. In addition, it is a place to have a night out with friends due to its lodge-like setting.
There is a lot to taste here – nicely prepared burgers, salads, and chicken wings made from scratch to retain their freshness. Start with a plate of fried chicken or smoke-grilled pulled pork. Then, send it down with a mug of beer or alcoholic selections.
While relaxing for your promptly served meal, you will watch your best NFL on the television. It has a welcoming ambiance that makes it a comfortable place to stop for an evening treat. Also, you can bring your friends, family, and colleagues for a hangout. Everything feels great here.
Twin Peaks Restaurants is open on Sunday to Thursday, from 11 am – 11:45 pm, and Friday to Saturday, from 11 – 1:30 am.
Address: 6880 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 913-0992
7. The Melting Pot
When it comes to gourmet fondue, give it to The Melting Pot. It has existed since 1975, serving locals and tourists in an intimate atmosphere.
If you want something that hits the spot, you should go for the Big Night Out Dinners for Two. It includes your preferred cheese, entrée, salad, and chocolate fondue. In addition, a plate of fresh seafood paired with a glass of wine will make the night memorable.
Te Melting Pot is one of the best places to eat in Castleton, Indiana, if you seek a place to have a romantic dinner. You can also connect with friends or take the family on a special treat in this hotspot. Aside from the delectable meal, there is a lot to do here; come and see things yourself.
The Melting Pot is open on Monday to Thursday, from 4 – 9 pm, Friday, from 4 – 10 pm, Saturday, from 12 – 10 pm, and Sunday, from 12 – 9 pm.
Address: 5650 E 86th St Ste A, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 841-3601
8. The Journey
Located in the Indianapolis Pavilion Corner Shops, The Journey is an exclusive restaurant offering delectable sushi, seafood and prime rib choices. So, if you care for a dish of Japanese-inspired food with American twists, you can check out this place. You will enjoy a relaxed meal with its stylish décor and cozy atmosphere.
Only the finest and freshest ingredients make it to the kitchen, which is evident in the flavor of the food before you. Check out the Maki list comprising over 30 sushi and sashimi selections if you want to go on an adventure to Japan. If not, a simple dish of slow-roasted prime rib, served with your choice salad, will hit the spot well.
At the entrance, the warm atmosphere sweeps you off your feet and lands you on your seat. You can come alone or in the company of your loved ones; it does not change the experience. There are also party rooms for private parties, special occasions, or dining. It feels like a journey to the food island once you step in.
The Journey is open on Monday to Friday, from 11 am – 3 pm, and Saturday to Sunday, from 11 am – 11:30 pm.
Address: 7155 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 578-9933
Planning a road trip in Indiana, check out our guide on things to do in Carmel and things to do in Fort Wayne for a fun time, create your bucket list now!.
9. Thai Orchid
If you crave Thai food in a laid-back restaurant while in Castleton, Thai Orchid promises an unforgettable dining experience, as it’s one of the remarkable Castleton restaurants. The restaurant provides a perfect environment to eat hearty meals, served hot and prompt. The delectable food has a warm and comfortable taste, making you come for more.
You can request a lunch special of spring rolls, soups, and salads. However, if you crave something from the heart of Thailand, then Pad Thai noodles, a dish comprising stir-fried rice noodles in a homemade sauce, is spot-on.
Nothing beats eating your favorite Thai food in an unpretentious setting, indoors or outdoors. The premium service is stellar and the staff is courteous enough to ensure you are satisfied. Besides, the value you derive here does not eat into your pocket. So, make it your go-to restaurant whenever you pass by.
Thai Orchid is open on Monday to Thursday, from 11 am – 9 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 11 am – 10 pm, and Sunday, from 12 – 9 pm.
Address: 8145 Bash St, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 578-8155
10. One World Market Food Court
This is another Japanese hotspot in Castleton, where you can eat rolls of sushi to your satisfaction and step out filled. It offers more than food and grocery. It also has a store selling a variety of Japanese items. In-house chefs are on standby to make your meal as you order it so you can have a fresh delight.
Have you imagined what a taste of cold Asian wine, beer, and spirits could be on a warm evening after work? What about combining your choice with a plate of seafood salad and California rolls? This restaurant offers all these and more.
It offers home-style comfort, so guests can always count on them for fulfilled dining. Whether you desire brunch, lunch, or dinner, you will find some gracious offerings to make your day memorable.
One World Market Food Court is open on Monday to Friday, from 10 am – 7:30 pm, and Sunday, from 10 am – 7 pm.
Address: 8466 Castleton Corner Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46250. Phone: (317) 842-3442
11. LongHorn Steakhouse
This is a popular modest steakhouse with chains of branches throughout the country. Longhorn Steakhouse, established in 1981, has proven that it is reliable regarding American-style meals and BBQs in a ranch-style atmosphere. So when looking for a place to have a laid-back dinner with your loved ones, there is no better place than LongHorn Steakhouse.
The menu features flavorful favorites like ribeye sandwiches, fresh seafood, mushroom starters, parmesan-crusted chicken, steakhouse cheeseburgers, slow-cooked baby-back ribs, and lots of chocolate options. There is also a range of drinks and homemade sides that would pair perfectly with whatever you crave.
Feel free to choose; everything is served at a fantastic rate and in significant portions. So come in today and experience premium service in an inviting atmosphere.
LongHorn Steakhouse is open on Sunday to Thursday, from 11 am – 10 pm, and Friday to Saturday, from 11 am – 11 pm.
Address: 5910 E 82nd St, Castleton, IN, 46250. Phone: (317) 595-0094
12. Wolfies at Geist
If you prefer to dine in a waterfront sports bar along Geist Marina, you would love to step into Wolfies at Geist and savor some delightful food. Aside from the raw bar with classic American fare, you will enjoy nice tunes from live music. How about coming with your special one, hand-in-hand, for an intimate dinner while enjoying the lakefront view?
Its extensive menu features many favorites, but you can start with Soy-Glazed Brussels Sprouts, made of fried Brussels sprouts, soy chili glaze, feta cheese, bacon, and dried cranberries. Alternatively, you will enjoy a mouthwatering seafood option – the Mango Mahi Mahi, comprising blackened Mahi Mahi, sesame Thai, fried rice, and pineapple mango chutney.
Life has not been sweeter than dining in a lively atmosphere overlooking the Geist Reservoir. So ensure to make here a compulsory place to visit once you come around, as it is one of the best restaurants in Castleton, Indiana.
Wolfies at Geist is open from Monday to Thursday, 11 am – 11 pm, and Friday to Saturday, 11 – 12 am.
Address: 11699 Fall Creek Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46256. Phone: (317) 913-0293
13. Fort Harrison State Park Inn
This charming restaurant is located right in Fort Harrison State Park and has existed since 1940. It serves fresh family-style meals and some Indiana fare. You can come for breakfast or lunch, or even a buffet dinner.
The extensive menu features diverse specialties with eclectic tastes you cannot resist. Nothing has been more refreshing than starting your day with biscuits and gravy, egg dishes, carved roast beef, pit ham, or Swai and Catfish. Finally, pick some treats for a dessert or a glass of a cold drink.
In addition, you can choose to celebrate your special day here, as it has a Blue Heron ballroom accommodating around 320 guests. You can also give your family special treats over a casual meal.
Address: 6002 N Post Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46216. Phone: (317) 638-6000
14. Arni’s River Ridge
If you are around 96th Street and need a casual restaurant to give your taste some special treat, Arni’s River Ridge is a perfect spot and one of the top restaurants in Castleton, Indiana. It is a popular family-owned restaurant, providing a casual menu comprising pasta dishes, pizzas, soups, wings, and Italian sandwiches.
The restaurant also has an elegant space with wooden tables and chairs, fancy lights, and suspended ceilings to host colleagues, friends, and family. You can make new friends from the new faces chatting, laughing, and willing to turn strangers into friends. Undoubtedly, it is a favorite spot for sharing exciting moments.
Arni’s River Ridge is open on Monday to Thursday, from 11 am – 10 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 11 am – 11 pm, and Sunday, from 11 am – 9 pm.
Address: 4705 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240. Phone: (317) 571-0077
15. Pizza King of Carmel
Conveniently located in Carmel Office Court is Pizza King of Carmel, a family-friendly pizzeria in Indianapolis. It also offers takeout and delivery options for anyone who may not make it here. The meals served are known for their consistency in flavor, which means you will be satisfied with your choice.
It is normal not to crave pizza all the time, and that is why we recommend other options like pasta dishes, chicken sandwiches, and a complementary beer, soft drink, or wine. Meals are always hot and delicious; hence you shouldn’t miss coming for a nice treat.
This place is not the usual fanciful restaurant, but its simple décor makes it spot-on for casual dining. The atmosphere and customized service uplift your mood, providing an unforgettable experience.
Pizza King of Carmel is open on Monday to Thursday, from 11 am – 10 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 11 am – 11 pm, and Sunday, from 4 – 10 pm.
Address: 301 E Carmel Dr, Carmel, IN 46032. Phone: (317) 848-7994
Map of the Best Restaurants in Castleton, Indiana
To get around during your trip to Castleton, here is a map of the best restaurants in Castleton with markers of the top places to eat in Castleton, Indiana
Are you considering exploring Indiana, here is a list of things to do Terre Haute and things to do in South Bend, and for a fun vacation
Plan a Visit to Castleton
The above outstanding Castleton restaurants are all unique, with special dishes you would love to try. You can check them out for proximity before making your choice.
But you will certainly not regret dining in any of them. A memorable experience awaits you in Castleton!