Are you making travel plans to Fish Creek, WI, in the USA? If so, you’ve come to the right place.
Fish Creek is an unincorporated community of Gibraltar town in Door County, WI. It was established in the late 1800s. Fish Creek’s stunning surroundings and proximity to Peninsula Bay led to its development as a well-liked tourist resort.
This beautiful city is an established summer vacation spot for its scenic beauty, outdoor recreation, and cultural attractions, including its historic structures, art galleries, and theaters.
Fish Creek restaurants are among what make visitors to keep returning. They offers outstanding meals, which in turn enhances the overall experience in the community.
Check out the best restaurants in Fish Creek, WI.
Best Restaurants in Fish Creek, WI
1. White Gull Inn
Will you like to have some seafood dishes when you visit Fresh Creek, WI? If yes, White Gull Inn is your surest bet.
This ecstatic dining establishment serves exceptional seafood plates to diners. They are known for delicious lunch specials and candlelit dinners. You don’t want to miss their Door County whitefish boil, which is usually open yearly.
The restaurant has a general ambiance influenced by the water that will add to your memorable dining experience. They also have options for outdoor dining, allowing customers to enjoy their meal having beautiful views of the surrounding area.
They offer Outdoor Seating, Highchairs, Free Wifi, Credit Cards, Table Service, and wheelchair accessibility. Diners can enjoy the cool live music that plays in the background while dining.
There are various dishes on the White Gull Inn menu, including seafood, steak, pasta, salad, soup, sandwiches, desserts, cocktails, and options for a wine list to pair with the food.
White Gull Inn is one of the best places to eat in Fish Creek, WI. It is open Mondays to Sundays from 07:30 am to 08:00 pm.
Address: 4225 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9697, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-3517.
2. Julie’s Park Café
Julie’s Park Café and Motel is a traditional American eatery. It is situated outside Peninsula State Park, close to Fish Creek, Wisconsin’s northernmost point.
They have indoor and outdoor seating for a wonderful dining experience, and their hardworking and considerate staff work round the clock to attend to all diner’s needs.
At Julie’s Park Café, Breakfast and lunch are well-prepared, and the dishes are vegetarian-friendly. Walk in as strangers to sate your appetite with your choice of dish, and you’ll certainly leave as their friends.
Some features they offer are Free off-street parking, Highchairs, Wine and Beer, credit cards, and wheelchair accessibility.
Julie’s Park Café has a mouth-watering menu that will give your taste buds a nice treat, such as Eggs, Pancakes, Omelet, French toast, Cheese curds, Cherry crepes, Harsh brown sandwiches, etc.
Julie’s Park Café is open for business from Fridays to Sundays from 07:00 am to 02:00 pm.
Address: 4020 Highway 42, Fish Creek, WI 54212, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-2999
3. Whistling Swan Restaurant
Whistling Swan Restaurant is one of the top restaurants in Fish Creek, WI.
The Whistling Swan Restaurant was founded in Marinette, Wisconsin, in 1887. It is the oldest continually operating inn on the Door Peninsula.
This establishment has fine dining in a relaxing environment and a continuously changing menu prepared with local ingredients. It’s a wonderful place for having a very nice dinner because of their attentive service that always feels smooth.
Their staff is extremely welcoming and sincere and are known for delivering superb service. They provide gluten-free American cuisine and vegan options in a lovely environment with a decent selection of wines and appetizers.
Their menu includes shrimp, salad, whitefish, risotto, beef, striped bass, cheese, etc.
Whistling Swan Restaurant is open for business every Tuesday to Friday from 05:00 am to 09:00 pm.
Address: 4192 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9699, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-3442
4. Barringer’s Restaurant
Barringer’s Restaurant is one of the finest Fish Creek restaurants. In every sense, it is ideal with its excellent service.
This dining establishment is pricey, but you get quality when paying for their dishes.
The historic dining room and indoor/outdoor bar give the diners a true Barringer’s experience, with dishes made with handcrafted cocktails, regionally sourced ingredients, and a broad selection of wines.
They offer a full bar, parking, allow debit card, outdoor seating, and alcohol, and the facility is wheelchair accessible.
Their lunch and dinner meals include crab cakes, steak, lobster rolls, truffle fries, salad, carpaccio, cod, etc.
This restaurant is open Mondays to Sundays from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm.
Address:1 N Spruce St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9334, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-5445
5. FIKA Bakery and Café
Do you enjoy eating freshly baked food? FIKA Bakery and Café in Fresh Creek, WI, is your ideal choice.
The FIKA Bakery and Café is a charming dining establishment where you may relax with family and friends. This restaurant has a variety of flavourful dishes to consume and delectable drinks that are hot or cold to pair with your meal.
YlYou may unwind here while refueling with a delectable cup of Swedish coffee.
This bakery has several gluten-free alternatives along with freshly baked bread. The quiche and old-fashioned rolls are great choices if you want a heartier breakfast.
The services they offer include Out-door Seating, take-out, Dine-in, and In-store pickup, among others.
FIKA Bakery Cafe’s breakfast menu includes cinnamon rolls, Pecan or sticky almond buns, scones, muffins, breakfast souffle, chocolate chips, cookies, and dough cones.
The restaurant is only open on Saturdays and Sundays from 07:30 am to 03:00 pm.
Address:3903 State Highway 42, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9630, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-5105
6. Dippy’s Ice Cream Shop
Do you enjoy going out for ice cream on a warm evening after dinner? If that is the case, you should visit Dippy’s Ice Cream Shop.
At Dippy’s Ice Cream Shop, you may choose from a range of creamy and delicious ice cream. In this environment, there is simply ice cream, which you taste while conversing, having fun, and enjoying the cool evening breeze with companions.
Due to the variety of tastes, dark chocolate ice cream is one of the best you should try, and the serving size is so huge that you won’t be able to finish it.
Along with the gorgeous outside environment, there is a patio where you may enjoy your ice cream. Every staff you come into contact with at this delightful place is cheerful and friendly.
They provide a wide range of services, including outdoor seating, takeout, and other services. The facility is also wheelchair accessible.
Hippy-dippy, Waterbury, Dippy’s custard, whip, and pops are among the ice cream flavors available.
Visit Dippy’s Ice Cream Shop on Sundays to Saturdays from 11:00 a.m. to 09:30 p.m.
Address: Founders Square 4199 Main St, Fish Creek, WI, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-2395
7. Villaggios
Do you adore Italian cuisine? If yes, Villaggios restaurant is a place worth visiting.
Villaggios, which is one of top Fish Creek restaurants, delivers delectable and authentic Italian food to diners from all walks of life.
This beautiful dining establishment has a serene environment for all types of dining. If you have kids, it will be amazing to dine with them as they will enjoy coloring on the paper tablecloth while they wait for their preferred dishes to be served.
The wait staff in this dining establishment will give you and your kids a homely welcome and excellent service.
The restaurant has cozy furniture inside and a lovely interior for you to feel comfortable while dining.
Parking, highchairs, alcohol, table service, delivery, and bookings are just a few of the services they offer.
On their delectable menu, you will find pizza, salads, baked sandwiches, spaghetti, entrées, desserts, etc.
Villaggios is open for business on Fridays and Saturdays from 05:00 p.m. to 09:00 pm.
Address:4240 Juddville Rd, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9425, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-4646
8. Loft
If you like international and American cuisine, check out The Loft restaurant. It is one of the top restaurants in Fish Creek, WI.
This outstanding dining establishment in Northern Door County is the most well-known for welcoming diners from near and far. They provide more than just a wonderful dining experience in their lovely environment filled with skilled servers.
In addition to their elegant dining area, there are delectable dishes prepared here by seasoned chefs to sate your appetite and leave you drooling for more. Feel free to pair any of your meals with their liquors and cocktails at a reasonable price.
Loft features a full bar, free wifi, live music, etc., and the facility is wheelchair accessible.
Their menu includes a wide variety of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, entrees, draught beers, wines, liquors, and cocktails to accommodate every taste.
Loft restaurant is open Mondays to Sundays from 11:00 a.m. to 08:00 p.m.
Address:4170 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9699, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-5242.
Are you considering more exploration of Wisconsin? Here is our list of things to do in Manitowoc, things to do in Cottage Grove and things to do in Waunakee for a fun vacation.
9. Fish Creek Market
Do you want to pop by for a custom-made sandwich when you visit Fresh Creek, WI? Then consider Fish Creek Market.
For over 125 years, Fish Creek Market has operated as a family-run store that people frequent for souvenirs, artisanal foods, and locally produced goods.
You can also get a broad selection of wine, beer, and premium spirits from this modern market.
You will have a memorable experience at Fresh Creek Market because every waitperson you encounter is knowledgeable and helpful when making menu recommendations. They have a lovely storefront on the outside and a great lunch option.
You can take out whatever you order from Fresh Creek Market. Their menu includes mouth-watering delicacies like chips, deli sandwiches, bread, box lunches, sandwich orders, etc.
The restaurant is open Mondays to Sundays from 10:00 am to 03:00 pm.
Address:4164 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9699, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-3351
10. Kettle Black Fish Boil
Kettle Black Fish Boil is another outstanding establishment that is among the best restaurants in Fresh Creek, WI.
This ecstatic dining establishment is situated in one of Fish Creeks’ oldest still-standing historic buildings.
They offer indoor and outdoor seating options for customers to unwind and savor their meals while viewing the marina and harbor in Fresh Creek city. You can rely on this dining establishment to make the most of your getaway to Door County.
The flavors used to prepare the dishes served here are outstanding, the spices are excellent, and the portions are enormous. The environment is cozy and welcoming, and the service is prompt and friendly.
Online reservations are available and are quick and simple to make.
The Kettle Black Fish Boil menu features potatoes, cajun shrimp, and others. Their kid’s menu includes chicken tenders, hot dogs, a child’s kettle, blackfish boil, macaroni, and cheese.
They are open for business on Mondays to Sundays from 05:00 pm – 08:30 pm.
Address:4158 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9699 USA. Phone:+1 920-868-5215
11. Bayside Coffee
Bayside Coffee is a wonderful place frequented by locals. It is a charming little spot just close to the marina where you can enjoy a coffee and a snack. While the accommodating employees deliver their food, diners can relax on the spotless terrace.
The services they offer include outdoor seating, takeout, free WiFi, street parking, credit card processing, and river views. The facility is wheelchair accessible.
Bayside Coffee is open Mondays to Sundays from 7:00 am to 02:00 pm.
Address:4151 Maple St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9336, USA. Phone:+1 920-495-8338.
12. Shiny Moon Café
Are you trying to find the best coffee shop in Fresh Creek, WI? In that case, choosing Shiny Moon Cafe is the right move.
The owners and managers of the Shiny Moon Café are Angie and John McMahon. They are recognized for providing delectable vegetarian, meat, and vegan options while offering patrons a wonderful dining experience in their welcoming setting.
Their friendly on-call team will greet you with a smile and give you their full attention from the moment you enter till the moment you leave. The lovely local artists’ drawings are available for diners to admire while dining.
Their menu includes cookies, multi-greened salad, breakfast biscuits, pastries, sandwiches, soups, skillets, roasted Cauliflower, etc.
Shiny Moon Cafe is open for business from Mondays to Sundays from 08:00 am to 02:00 pm.
Address:4164 Main St 2nd Floor Second Floor, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9699, USA. Phone:+1 920-493-1519
13. Greenwood Supper Clubs
Greenwood Supper Clubs is a steakhouse and American cuisine restaurant. It is one of the best places to eat in Fresh Creek, WI.
Greenwood Supper Clubs, established in 1930, is a beautiful dining establishment where diners would want to spend their magnificent evening.
Meals are freshly served whenever you need them, and there is always a good amount of food at dinner, cooked to your specifications. The friendly staff here will contribute to your amazing dining experience, and you will crave a second visit.
This restaurant’s enticing service includes table service, a full bar, television, and alcohol, and the facility is Wheelchair accessible.
On their menu are mouth-watering dishes to give your tastebuds a nice treat, including steaks, deep-fried shrimp, deep-fried scallops, salads, bread, etc.
Greenwood Supper Clubs are open from Mondays to Sundays from 04:00 pm to 09:00 pm.
Address: N9087 County Road A, Fish Creek, WI 54212, USA. Phone:+1 920-839-2451
14. Grumpy’s Fish Creek
Grumpy’s Fish Creek is a family-run dining establishment that originated in Egg Harbor and later made its way to Fish Creek, where it developed. They are known for selling homemade popcorn, ice cream, fudge, and root beer.
They provide a bigger portion of whatever you order at a fair price. Patrons takeout their orders and head to the shoreline to watch the sunset.
You can grab a quick treat at Grumpy’s with your family and friends, and you will not fail to want more. Their staff is always polite and ready to serve all diners delicious, locally-made ice cream in a selection of cones and cups.
Takeout is available at Grumpy’s , and the facility is wheelchair accessible.
They provide a variety of treats on their menu, including butter pecan ice cream, butter popcorn, mushroom popcorn, kettle corn, and caramel ice cream.
Grumpy’s Fish Creek is open Tuesdays to Saturdays from 11:00 am to 08:00 pm and Sundays from 11:00 am to 04:00 pm.
Address:9431 Spruce St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9302, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-5700
15. Blue Horse Café
Blue Horse Café has been open since 2001, offering delicious pastries, an espresso bar, and breakfast and lunch meals to all diners who pay a visit.
Many customers who have dined there agree that it is one of their favorite places to get coffee when visiting Door County due to the warm ambiance, wonderful food, courteous service, and friendly personnel.
They have various vegetarian options for breakfast and lunch, accessible all day. You have a lovely view of the entire beach in a pleasant environment while dining in this elegant dining establishment.
The waterfront setting, free wifi, credit card acceptance, outdoor seating, takeout, etc., are just a few of the Café’s amazing features.
You can order delicacies like sandwiches, pasta salad, coffee drinks, eggs, porches, and cottages from their menu.
Blue Horse Cafe is usually open from Mondays to Sundays from 07:00 am to 05:00 pm.
Address:4113 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212-9699, USA. Phone:+1 920-868-1471.
Map of the Best Restaurants in Fish Creek, WI
To get around during your trip to Fish Creek, here is a map of the best restaurants in Fish Creek with markers of the top places to eat in Fish Creek, WI.
Are you considering more exploration of Wisconsin? Here is our list of things to do in Neenah, things to do in Bayfield and things to do in Eagle River for a fun vacation.
Plan a Trip to Fish Creek
Fish Creek, WI, is a fantastic destination for a family vacation.
What is a vacation without food? Fortunately, there are numerous Fish Creek restaurants. The quantity of food served at theses restaurants are large. So you are bound to eat to your satisfaction.
Tru to have something new when you visit. Dining in this community is something you’ll enjoy.