15 Best Restaurants in Reynoldsburg (Ohio)

Located just a short drive from Columbus, is Reynoldsburg, a family-friendly city that is perfect for a getaway. Reynoldsburg is situated in Franklin, Licking, and Fairfield counties in Ohio, United States.

Reynoldsburg, Ohio may not be the first destination that comes to mind when you think of a vacation spot, but it has a lot to offer! This city had a population of 41,050 people in 2021.

It will interest you to know that the oldest marketed cultivar of tomato was developed and distributed in Reynoldsburg, earning it the nickname, “The Birthplace of the Tomato” in the early 1800s.

If you are looking for some of the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, you have come to the right place, as this beautiful city has some excellent dining options to choose from. Some of the local favorites include La Fogata Grill, The Winking Lizard, and Scali Ristorante.

Reynoldsburg also offers a mix of outdoor activities, local culture, and proximity to larger attractions including Huber Park, and the Blacklick Creek Greenway Trail.

Let’s explore the top restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio.

Best Restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio

1. Scali Ristorante

Scali Ristorante

Scali Ristorante, established in 1993 in a shopping plaza in the Reynoldsburg area, was initially a vision of Frank and his father, Antonio when they left for the United States.

Scali was once a 70-seat restaurant, but thanks to the diligence, tenacity, and delectable Italian treats they are famous for, this establishment has grown to a 120-seat restaurant, and they show no indications of slowing down their success.

With its fantastic Italian cuisine, Scali has a flourishing luncheon service sector, and soon they also plan on providing catering services. Their available services include takeouts for customers who wish to enjoy their meals at home or a different location, reservations, and delivery.

At the heart of Italian cuisine are fresh, seasonal ingredients like garlic, olive oil, basil, and real cheeses, which are simple, yet full of flavor. This restaurant employs those ingredients to prepare delectable dishes such as tiramisu, peasant tortellini, broccoli, linguini with clams, and cannoli. It’s no surprise it’s one of the top restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio.

Visit Scali Ristorante from 5:00 pm to 8:00 pm Tuesdays through Saturdays.

Address: 1903 OH- 256, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-759-7764.

2. Smokey Bones

Smokey Bones

Smokey Bones is a pub and top Reynoldsburg barbecue restaurant known for its outstanding food, fine wines, and well-brewed beverages. 

There are loads of enjoyable activities to partake in while you’re at Smokey Bones such as live performances, sports, and lots of surprises.

In addition to traditional indoor seating, Smokey Bones offers an outdoor seating option which is the best place to enjoy a meal while soaking up the sun during the warmer months, and in case you don’t want to dine in the restaurant, they provide takeout and delivery services.

Smokey Bones consistently provides delicious food like smoked chicken wings, pretzel bones, hand-pulled pork platter, fried pickles, and baked potato and salad.

They are open throughout the week from 11:00 am to 1:00 pm.

Address: 2200 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-577-0764.

3. La Fogata Grill

La Fogata Grill

One of the best places to eat in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, is La Fogata Grill, a beloved fixture in the community. With numerous years of expertise, the chefs at this Reynoldsburg restaurant are incredibly skilled so you can be sure of having exquisite meals.

This restaurant is made up of a team of highly trained and attentive individuals and prides itself on providing top-notch apt services to its guests. The servers here are also responsible for maintaining a clean and organized dining room.

One of the standout features of La Fogata Grill is its extensive menu which comprises a wide variety of Mexican dishes such as carne asada fries, seafood soup, fajita steak salad, and tortilla soup.

Whether you are in the mood for a refreshing frozen margarita or a sit-down dinner of chicken fajitas with friends, La Fogata Grill has something that suits everyone. So come on by and experience the taste of Mexico in the heart of Reynoldsburg, Ohio!

Visit La Fogata Grill from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm on Mondays to Saturdays, and 11:00 am to 9:00 pm on Sundays.

Address: 1849 Winderly Ln, Pickerington, OH 43147, United States. Phone: +1 614-864-9154.

4. The Hickory House

The Hickory House

A delicious steak paired with a few beers or cocktails is sometimes the best thing in the world, and if this is exactly what you’ve been looking for, you should visit The Hickory House at Reynoldsburg, Ohio.

Since 1979, this restaurant has succeeded in providing the community with excellent steak, superior and unmatched customer service, and devoted employees. This family-run company takes pride in its exceptional value, which has elevated it to the top steakhouse in the neighborhood.

The wheelchair-accessible services in this restaurant allow for easy maneuverability and access and make dining out a more enjoyable experience for individuals who use wheelchairs. They are also popular for curbside pickup, high chairs, a fantastic bar on site, and free Wi-Fi.

They offer everything from hand-cut steaks, barbecue ribs, chicken Alfredo, sweet corn nuggets, onion wings, fish and chips, Porterhouse steak dinner, and Idaho baked potatoes.

Operating hours are Mondays to Thursdays from 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm, weekends from 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm, and Sundays from 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm.

Address: 7051 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-861-5962.

5. City Barbeque

City Barbeque

“The art and soul for BBQ” is the popular slogan of City Barbeque. This restaurant sits comfortably among some of the best places to eat in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, and this is because they don’t simply serve their dishes with just meat and a little bit of heat.

City Barbeque understands that there’s a lot of action that goes into making a superb barbecue and so the employees here work hard to ensure that the quality of their meals overrides the quantity and that customers are given only the best.

Since 1999, they have maintained their mission of serving and bringing enjoyment to Reynoldsburg in addition to providing wonderful food and barbecue. This restaurant offers physical gift cards, e-gift cards, and merch for customers who need them or wish to gift them to their loved ones.

Enjoy pulled pork, beef brisket, brisket sandwich, premium salad, mac and cheese, half chicken, ribs, grilled chicken, hush puppies, and other yummy delicacies on the menu.

Drop by City Barbecue Mondays through Saturdays from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm and Sundays from 11:00 am to 8:00 pm.

Address: 5979 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213, United States. Phone: +1 614-755-8890.

6. Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery

Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery

The dream for Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery was driven by Bryan Tyler’s love of creating wholesome baked goods. Tyler’s Pizzeria is big on making tasty, distinctive pizzas using only the freshest ingredients.

This restaurant ensures maximum quality and flavor by going against the norm of outlets nationwide and the artificially induced items and processed foods they sell. They are at the forefront of offering the best pizza and food in Reynoldsburg.

Tyler’s offers al fresco dining which is the perfect spot to enjoy a slice of pizza on a warm, summer afternoon, and for those who prefer to enjoy their meals elsewhere, they offer a convenient takeaway service.

The pizzas are made with handmade dough and topped with various flavorful portions of meat, vegetables, and cheeses according to customers’ preferences, but if you are in the mood for something else, Tyler’s also serves pastries like scones, croissants, pepperoni rolls, and cookies.

So next time you’re craving pizza in Reynoldsburg, make sure to stop by Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery!

Opening Hours are Wednesdays through Fridays from 3:00 pm to 9:00 pm, and Saturdays from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm.

Address: 7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-322-9587.

7. The Winking Lizard

The Winking Lizard

Winking Lizard Tavern, a family-run establishment that began its operation in 1983 on Miles Road in Bedford Heights, holds a plethora of noteworthiness.

This establishment has been honored by locals as one of the best Reynoldsburg restaurants due to its variety and outstanding performance as more than just an eatery that serves award-winning meals and a market yardstick for the most cutting-edge craft beer menu in the city.

You can hang out with friends and family at their sports bar and watch your preferred games on the available TVs while enjoying a cold glass of rum. This restaurant has developed into a second home that is rooted in unwavering relationships, heritage, and family.

For more than 30 years, The Winking Lizard has provided off-site catering services for events such as weddings, birthday parties, business gatherings, and much more, making it easy to feed a crowd with their tasty offerings.

You can order baby back ribs, buffalo mac and cheese, tiramisu, Joe’s American chili, grilled chicken teriyaki, strip steak, potato skins, boneless wings, and chicken breasts from the menu.

Visit Winking Lizard Mondays through Thursdays from 11:30 am to 11:00 pm, on weekends from 11:30 am to 11:30 pm, and Sundays from 11:30 am to 9:30 pm.

Address: 7995 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-490-3070.

8. Loving Hut

Loving Hut

Loving Hut is a Reynoldsburg establishment that focuses on vegans and patrons who like to eat healthy.

The goal of this restaurant is to provide customers with wholesome, organic alternatives. It uses healthful products and offers a practical reference point for people intending to switch to a more organic diet.

Loving Hut provides a wide variety of options available for you, whether you are on the go or just want to take a break and relax. If you are looking to add a bit of flair to your event, their catering options might just be a fantastic choice.

Their menu is filled with dishes like spicy nuggets, mini spring rolls, Soba noodles, chili fries, vegan carrot cake, green curry, vegan nuggets, orange delight, house salad, and vegan pho.

Opening hours are 12:00 pm to 7:00 pm every Wednesday to Saturday.

Address: 6569 E Livingston Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-863-0823.

Are you considering more exploration of Ohio? Here is our list of things to do in Mason and things to do in Chillicothe for a fun vacation.

9. Massey’s Pizza

Massey’s Pizza

The story of the history of Massey’s Pizza can be traced back to 1949, when the Massucci brothers, Dan and Jim first served pizza to the diners at Columbus. That was when Massey’s Pizza began a long-lasting relationship with pizza lovers in the region.

Up till today, Massey’s is still capturing the hearts, and more importantly, the stomachs of pizza fans all over the region. They are wholly imbibed in the culture of handing and delivering top-notch meals along with excellent customer service.

This restaurant uses Italian meatballs and sausages that are prepared in-house, an abundance of cheese, and mozzarella toppings, on their pizzas. They also provide other dishes like chicken cheddar bacon, PBLTs, and strombolis.

You can visit from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm on weekdays and 11:00 am to 10:00 pm on weekends.

Address: 7070 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-868-0690.

10. Vick’s Gourmet Pizza

Vick’s Gourmet Pizza

Vick’s Gourmet Pizza has been serving customers scrumptious, fresh pizza, and a variety of delectable appetizers since 1961. This family run establishment is one of the best restaurants in Reynoldsbur, Ohio, famous for serving comfort food in a family-friendly environment.

The employees always endeavor to guarantee the pizzeria upholds exceptional values of authenticity they have since promoted by making zesty pizzas and specials every day with original and custom sauces and locally sourced meats.

This old-school parlor offers outdoor seating, curbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options for guests. Their wheelchair accessibility for disabled customers is a fantastic inclusion to the overall dining experience.

The menu features meatball subs, garlic bread and cheese, BBQ grilled chicken, tacos, calzones with custom fillingchicken wings, pizza, bread sticks, and pasta.

Visit Vick’s Gourmet Pizza today for an amazing, fun-filled experience. They welcome guests Tuesdays through Sundays from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm and Mondays from 2:00 pm to 10:00 pm.

Address: 7345 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-866-7392.

11. SC Bar & Kitchen

SC Bar & Kitchen

The best American cuisine is usually accompanied by a few cocktails or beers, and sometimes this is all it takes for a one-of-a-kind dining adventure. SC Bar & Kitchen, a privately run pub was established on the foundation of producing top-notch, and savory contemporary culinary experiences. 

This restaurant fuses Creole, American, Korean, and Cajun food influences to produce the mouthwatering dishes they are popular for. SC Bar & Kitchen is also a pioneer in the entertainment department with a range of entertainment options perfect for any kind of event. 

Its features made it to reputed one of the top restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio.

They provide activities for everyone, whether you want to blow off some steam with friends over a few drinks, belt out your favorite song at the karaoke, engage in various bar games, watch a game for the sports enthusiasts, or listen to some live music.

You can enjoy some of your favorite meals like chicken breast sandwiches, Korean dumplings, BLT, classic wings with celery, fish or chicken dinner, shrimp and grits, and turkey club and pair it with their signature house cocktails like pineapple vodka, peach schnapps, and svedka cherry.

Hours of operation are from 12:00 pm to 9:00 pm on Sundays to Wednesdays, Thursdays from 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm, and weekends from 12:00 pm to 11:00 pm.

Address: 1921 OH-256, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-863-1004.

12. Cajun Boil Bar

Cajun Boil Bar

Dining at Cajun Boil Bar is unquestionably one of the best experience you can have while visiting the city of Reynoldsburg, Ohio, especially if you love seafood. This bar provides a dining area with some of the city’s best seafood dishes, delivered in a soothing environment.

This restaurant believes in the accessibility of food for every patron, both old and new and therefore they offer a variety of options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery.

Furthermore, if you want to impress your guests with some delicious seafood dishes, the team of experienced chefs and event coordinators is always available to create a memorable and sublime eating experience for you and your guests.

The menu comprises fried crab cakes, chicken Alfredo, snow crab legs, fish PO boy, jambalaya, clams, hush puppies, calamari, deep-fried Oreos, and Cajun boil.

Drop by Cajun Boil Bar every Tuesday to Saturday from 12:00 pm to 10:30 pm and Sundays and Mondays from 12:00 pm to 9:30 pm.

Address: 2760 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-863-8667.

13. Dubar Nepali and Indian Cuisine

Dubar Nepali and Indian Cuisine

Are you an Indian food enthusiast and a lover of everything from momo dumplings to garlic naan, and chicken tikka masala? Dubar Nepali and Indian Cuisine is the restaurant for you! This restaurant is a blend of traditional and contemporary Indian meals.

With a commitment to using fresh and quality ingredients in the preparation of meals, Dubar Nepali continues to be the best spot for lunch and dinner with family and friends. Their services include free Wi-Fi, curbside pickup, delivery, and a bar on site.

Enjoy your favorite Indian meals such as paneer tikka masala, chicken soup, goat biryani, pork sekuwa, tandoori chicken, vegetable samosa, thali, and chicken chow mein.

They are open from 11:30 am to 9:30 pm on Tuesdays to Saturdays.

Address: 7621 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-986-9621.

14. Sargam Restaurant and Bar

Sargam Restaurant and Bar

If you have never tried innovative food combinations and fusion cuisines, you are missing out on a lot! Fusion foods are simple recipes that incorporate flavors and ingredients from different cuisines or civilizations to create a wholly new dish.

Sargam is a unique diner that combines elements of Indian, Nepalese, and Tibetan traditions to produce its distinctive cuisine. It is one of the outstanding Reynoldsburg restaurants.

The dishes here are made by the executive chef who has masterfully perfected the technique of harmonizing flavors and uses old, long-time recipes to please every palate. If dining in at the establishment does not appeal to you, you can opt for their delivery services or take their food on the go.

Try out their lamb, garlic naan, chicken biryani, veggie pakora, pork thali, chicken makhani butter chicken, mango lassi, samosa chaat, palak panner, curry goat, and vegetable fried rice.

They operate Tuesdays through Sundays from 11:00 am to 9:30 pm, and Mondays from 3:00 pm to 9:30 pm.

Address: 1371 Hentz Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-892-7474.

15. First Watch

First Watch


With several other locations, First Watch has been a staple in the Reynoldsburg community and it is easy to see why. This restaurant is a popular spot for breakfast and lunch dishes, and it excels at both classic and avant-garde delicacies.

They are also famous for amazing coffee and a great tea selection. With delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options, you can enjoy your meals anytime, anywhere.

First Watch boasts an impressive customer service reputation and a menu that offers an extensive selection in addition to a seasonal variety of creative specialties crafted with the best quality ingredients. The treats served include shrimp and grits, Belgian waffles, and lemon ricotta pancakes.

They are open from 7:00 am to 2:30 pm every day.

Address: 2227 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Road, OH-256, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-864-3447.

Map of the Best Restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio 

To get around during your trip to Reynoldsburg, here is a map of the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg with markers of the top places to eat in Reynoldsburg, Ohio.


Are you considering more exploration of Ohio? Here is our list of things to do in Yellow Springs, things to do in Marblehead and things to do in Youngstown for a fun vacation.

Plan a Visit To Reynoldsburg

Reynoldsburg, Ohio, is a great destination for a vacation, with its numerous amazing attractions and dining establishments to explore. Reynoldsburg restaurants will undoubtedly appeal to people of all ages and various preference.

Whether you are interested in exploring the city’s heritage offerings, or just want to relax and enjoy the great outdoors, Reynoldsburg is the place where all the fun resides. Do visit!